The Best Seafood Dives Coast to Coast

Long live the laid-back shacks where the menus hang on the wall, the beers chill on ice, and the food comes piled high, deep-fried, slathered, breaded, buttered, and steamed.

New York's Best Seafood Dives

We've found some keepers in these casual New York coastal joints.

  • Print
  • |
  • Email

New York Seafood Dive

Illustrator Matt Caserta

Click to Enlarge

The Clam Bar at Napeague, Amagansett
What to expect: Few summer pleasures can match devouring a plate of steamed clams—or whatever your seafood pleasure—in the salty open air at The Clam Bar, not caring whether the juices dribble onto your chin, your beach attire, or the pebbles underfoot. Open early May until early fall, depending on the weather; cash only.
Check it out: 2025 Montauk Highway (Route 27); 631/267-6348 or

Orient By the Sea Restaurant & Marina, Orient Point
What to expect: Go for the hot flounder sandwich or the de-shelled Lazy Lobster.
Check it out: 40200 Main Road; 631/323-2424 or

P.J. Lobster House, Port Jefferson
What to expect: Stick with the steamer clams and the steamed lobster. Seafood market/restaurant.
Check it out: 1 North Country Road; 631/473-1143 or

Wheeler's Restuarant, Brooklyn, New York
What to expect: Proudly ungentrified (with a "No Sushi" sign in the window), this neighborhood bar serves wonderful steamed mussels with white or red sauce.
Check it out: 1707 Sheepshead Bay Road; 718/646-9320

Page 1

More Ways To Get Coastal Living



JavaScript must be enabled to use this Calendar module.

20 Beautiful Beach Cottages

From polished and sophisticated to rustic and casual, browse through this roundup of beach cottages to find your favorite coastal style.

Room to Breathe