—Jennifer Brunnemer Slaton
Dine: The Caves bypasses the typical buffets and instead serves fresh, organic food grown on local farms. Order the "combo" so you can try everything. The banana pancakes and the Jamaican jerk chicken are musts.
Don't miss: Go underwater with Paul, the resort's outdoors guide: He'll take you snorkeling in caves (including a bat cave!). Reserve the private hot tub at sunset for a fab view.
Rates start at $445; islandoutpost.com.