Top 10 All-Inclusive Caribbean Resorts
—Marion Laffey Fox
Dine: Here, the five-star dining revolves around locally source ingredients interpreted in Indian, Chinese, and Jamaican-kissed fare: spiced king fish with jasmine rice and jerk chicken wontons with mango chutney? So awesome.
Don't miss: Learn how to make some of your favorite dishes from the resort in a cooking class. It's pure fun hanging out with the chef in the alfresco kitchen, using organic vegetables from the garden and Caribbean spices. (Book in advance; the class fills up fast.)
Rates start at $920; hermitagebay.com.
Dine: All meals are served in Windsong (although the swim-up bar serves a casual lunch menu) or via room service; the menu has an Asian twist, but still draws on local produce and island flavors like the smoky St. Lucian crab backs with mango mojo on organic leaves, and the local octopus tempura with tart pickled ginger and fresh spicy chili seaweed.
Don't Miss: The swim-up bar is the place to be at sunset with a drink in hand. (Try the Lucian Mama, a sweet concoction of orange juice, banana, cacao Creole, and dark rum.) Then watch the golden sun disappear into the sea from the edge of the infinity pool.
Rates start at $595; calabashcove.com.
—Marion Laffey Fox
Dine: Breakfast, lunch, and dinner are served in The Verandah, the buzzy matrix of the resort, with an inspired menu—anything from grilled lobster to house-made mango tarts—that also can be enjoyed on the beach with your toes in the sand.
Don't Miss: Book a stargazing night on Pasture Bay Beach, where the staff will set up lounge chairs for you to spot brilliant constellations and will fill a basket with gourmet treats and champagne.
Rates start at $1,550; rosewoodhotels.com.
Dine: The open-air Cariblue Restaurant is your not-so-typical buffet for breakfast and lunch with an extensive fresh salad bar and made-to-order dishes. The Deli and Clubhouse serve casual meals and drinks, but it's TAO restaurant that takes dining to a new level. The romantic location on a second-tier balcony offers a similar Pan-Asian menu to other TAO locations, including tender flat iron steak with bok choy and a smoky eggplant puree.
Don't Miss: The piano bar is an old-school blast: Cozy up under soft candelabra light with a dry martini or scotch on the rocks and enjoy music from the baby grand piano.
Rates start at $900; thebodyholiday.com.
—Marion Laffey Fox
Dine: Breakfast and candlelight dinners are served in the breezy Tamarind Tree restaurant. Barefoot buffet lunches are far from ordinary, with plump barbecued shrimp and made-to-order gourmet sandwiches served in the open-air Beach Café & Bar
Don't Miss: Just a few minutes from the property is Nelson's Dockyard, a national park—the working marina is a great place to spend the afternoon admiring gleaming yachts and ships. It's also home to a collection of 18th-century structures that now house great boutiques, art galleries, and restaurants.
Rates start at $760; curtainbluff.com.
—Amy Lowe Mitchell
Dine: Local spices and ingredients are woven into every dish, from cream of breadfruit (a locally sourced starch) soup to nutmeg ice cream (exotic flavors made from scratch daily), served in open-air dining areas.
Don't Miss: Shop the nearby market for native spices, such as cloves and cinnamon, and hand-woven baskets. For an adventure, drive 20 minutes for a rain forest hike that leads to dramatic waterfalls and natural pools suited for swimming.
Rates start at $860; spiceislandbeachresort.com.
—Brielle M. Ferreira
Dine: Six à la carte restaurants and eight bars offer good variety for all palates. Try a light buffet lunch at the resort's Market Grill to leave room for an indulgent dinner at the Royal Service-exclusive Palazzo restaurant—the beef tenderloin truly shines thanks to a delightful, flavor-rich herb au jus.
Don't Miss: Head over to the Red Lounge or Gabi Beach for after-hours entertainment. Gabi Beach is a nod to Miami, with all-white lounges and tables right on the sand. During high season, the resort hosts daily dance parties that last well into the night. If you want to forgo the dancing and hole up in one spot, Red Lounge is a great alternative. Scarlet walls, crimson furniture, and ambient amber lighting give the place a cozier feel. The bar scene not your thing? Head back to your room early and ask your personal butler for a pillow menu to find the perfect pad for your weary head.
Rates start at $230 per person; paradisus.com.
—Jennifer Brunnemer Slaton
Dine: The Caves bypasses the typical buffets and instead serves fresh, organic food grown on local farms. Order the "combo" so you can try everything. The banana pancakes and the Jamaican jerk chicken are musts.
Don't miss: Go underwater with Paul, the resort's outdoors guide: He'll take you snorkeling in caves (including a bat cave!). Reserve the private hot tub at sunset for a fab view.
Rates start at $445; islandoutpost.com.
—Brielle M. Ferreira
Dine: Restaurants here specialize in five different cuisines, but if you're feeling a little homesick, you can still fill up on a full American breakfast in bed, complete with bacon and eggs, thanks to the Sanctuary's stellar room service. Just be sure to make it over to the resort's signature restaurant, the Blue Marlin, for lunch or dinner during your stay to get a taste of the incredible grilled tuna, caught daily by local fishermen.
Don't Miss: If you decide to spend your stay in one of the resort's exclusive Monarch Villas, you'll be able to watch the daily pink-and-purple sunsets from your own private porch on the beach,where the pristine white sand is nearly always deserted save for the occasional romantic wedding ceremony. If you find yourself in the mood for a tad more action, nearby Juanillo Beach is where the locals go to catch some rays.
Rates start at $188 per person; 809/562-9191.
Dine: All meals are served at Mango Bay's beachfront restaurant, where local produce and Barbados's signature breaded-and-fried flying fish are menu favorites. At the bar, try the deliciously fruity (and potent) Mango Bay Special rum cocktail.
Don't Miss: Sign up for a Catamaran Cruise (included) to get a tour of the island's west coast before snorkeling with sea turtles; a guide feeds them while you swim in the turquoise water with your new friends.
Rates start at $425; mangobaybarbados.com.