Between your room, the beach, and the restaurant, you'll have everything you need. From $425 to $1,595 (junior suite, high season); capjaluca.com.
Super Spa: CuisinArt Golf Resort & Spa
Try a massage with warmed seashells. From $400 to $1,020 (high season); cuisinartresort.com.
Sexy & Serene: Viceroy Anguilla
Sophistication comes to shore in this Kelly Wearstler-designed beauty. From $995 (resort-view room, high season); viceroyanguilla.com.
Euro Style: Malliouhana Hotel & Spa
Atop a lush, terraced bluff, this lodging overlooks Meads Bay and Turtle Cove beaches on the island's west end. From $430 to $1,120 (beachfront room); malliouhana.com.